Position Trading vs. Swing Trading: Differences, Similarities, and Which Can Be More Useful

Updated August 23, 2022 Guides

Position trading and swing trading are two prominent trading strategies that you can use to access the markets. Both methods provide market opportunities as you trade, but only if you understand their approaches.

Here, we’ll look at some similarities and differences and help you determine which can be more useful for your situation.

Position Trading vs. Swing Trading

Position trading is an option for you if:

  • You’re looking to make trades that last long periods (several months to years)
  • You have a strong bias towards fundamental analysis
  • You prefer making long-term investments
  • You’re averse to high-risk trading
  • You prefer trading with minimal leverage
  • You want a trading style with the least commissions and fees on trades

Swing trading is an option for you if:

  • You prefer opening trades that last between a few days and a few months
  • You want to trade after market closure
  • You prefer using technical analysis
  • You have an appetite for relatively high risk
  • You don’t want your capital locked away for extended periods

Similarities Between Position Trading and Swing Trading

Position trading and swing trading have some things in common. Here are a few of the similarities.

Both Trading Styles Have a Strong Bias Toward Fundamental Analysis

Both swing and position traders rely on fundamental analysis at some point to make decisions about going long or short.

Whether you’re a swing or position trader, you’ll understand from conducting fundamental analysis of the assets you’d like to trade. Take, for example, trading stocks of major companies. You can look at fundamental indicators like:

  • Projected Earnings Growth
  • Price to Book Ratio
  • Return on Equity etc[1]

You can also look at other fundamental drivers like inflation, government policy, and political stability, which can affect the markets.

Both Strategies Can Work in Any Market

Swing and position trading are flexible strategies that work across markets and timelines. You can use these two strategies no matter the instrument you’re trading.

Both Are Relatively Long-Term Trading Strategies

Unlike day trading, swing and position trading are long-term trading strategies. Swing trades can range between days and weeks, while position trades last much longer, spanning months and years.

That also means you’ll get into fewer positions during these periods as you attempt to create trading opportunities from any position you’re holding. While you may monitor charts and price movements, your trades will have a long-term bias.

Differences Between Position Trading and Swing Trading

There are several differences between position trading and swing trading. Here is the difference between the two trading styles.

Trading Frequency

As a trader, position trading lets you place trades for long periods. You lock in your capital on a trade over months or years by taking a position trade, and you may rarely change your position. You’ll trade more frequently with swing trading. Although you may also take months with this trading style, you’ll open and close positions more times than you would as a position trader[2].

Time Investment

Swing trading requires plenty of your time studying charts, back testing, and monitoring overall market trends [3].

You’ll need to monitor your trades daily and sometimes after several hours. Since swing trading is more unpredictable, you may have to change your strategy depending on market movements.

That means you’ll spend more time getting into and out of positions, unlike position trading.

With position trading, you don’t feel the effects of short-term trading. Once you take a position, you can potentially monitor it for progress every few weeks or months. That may give you time to focus on other activities that do not involve trading.

Transaction Volumes

Compared to position trading, swing trades contain more transactions within the same period a position trader would place their trades. You can open or close new trades with swing trading as you see fit.

With position trading, once you place a trade, you may await its final result after a few months or years.

Trading Opportunities

Swing trading may offer you more trading opportunities than position trading.

For instance, once you get into a long or short position, you’ll rarely divert your capital to other investments. However, swing trading takes advantage of short-term price movements, much like day trading.

That means you have more trading opportunities across different asset classes.

Choosing Between Position Trading and Swing Trading

Both position trading and swing trading have advantages and disadvantages. So, how do you know which trading style is ideal for you? Here are considerations to make when choosing a trading style.

Access to Capital

The amount of capital available in your account can help you determine which strategy to use. Although this rule is not hard and fast, most position traders have and use vast capital[4].

On the other hand, swing trading can work with a lower capital amount. Depending on your broker, you can start with as little as $1,500 or less as capital.

Emotional Management

Under normal circumstances, it can be more stressful to swing trade than to trade in positions. Swing trading requires better emotional management, especially when you experience drawdowns or lose trades. Since you’d deal with several trades within weeks, you need better emotional management.

Although emotional management is still essential with position trading, less stress is involved. Position trades take longer to mature, and you have less emotional instability as a result.

Fundamental vs. Technical Analysis

Although both swing and position traders may find fundamental analysis useful, many swing traders tend to use technical analysis[5]. Swing traders often use momentum and trend indicators to take advantage of short-term price movements in the markets.

Risk Appetite

Swing trading has a higher risk profile than position trading. That means you can potentially make gains on invested capital. However, you also face the risk of massive losses if you don’t use proper risk management strategies.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for relative stability, position trading offers may offer a more suitable opportunity. Price moves over months tend to be stable. You can enjoy some level of predictability in the markets. Although the risk of loss exists,

Final Thoughts

Both position and swing trading offer opportunities. Depending on your risk appetite, you may prefer one strategy over the other.


Start Trading with Vantage

Access markets including forex, commodities, indices, shares/stocks and more, at low cost.

Start trading by opening a live account here, or practice trading with virtual currency with a demo account.

You can also sign up for our free, weekly webinars that will break down the current markets as well as discuss potential trade set ups for the week.


References

  1. “Top 10 Fundamental Analysis Indicators For All Investors – Investor Academy”. Investor Academy, 2022, https://investoracademy.org/top-10-fundamental-analysis-indicators-for-all-investors/. Accessed 16 May 2022.
  2. “Day Trading Vs. Swing Trading”. The Balance, 2022, https://www.thebalance.com/day-trading-verus-swing-trading-4134456.
  3. “What Is Swing Trading?”. Investopedia, 2022, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/swingtrading.asp.
  4. “What Is Capital?”. Investopedia, 2022, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capital.asp.
  5. “Candlesticks and Oscillators for Successful Swing Trades”. Investopedia, 2022, https://www.investopedia.com/articles/trading/06/swingtrades.asp.

Disclaimer
Vantage does not represent or warrant that the material provided here is accurate, current, or complete, and therefore should not be relied upon as such. The information provided here, whether from a third party or not, is not to be considered as a recommendation; or an offer to buy or sell; or the solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any financial instruments; or to participate in any specific trading strategy. Any research provided does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any specific person who may receive it. We advise any readers of this content to seek their own advice. Past performance is not an indication of future results whereas reference to examples and/or charts is solely made for illustration and/or educational purposes. Without the approval of Vantage, reproduction or redistribution of this information is not permitted.

Latest Releases

Latest Releases

See All Articles >